Yellowstone True Story: How Accurate Is Taylor Sheridan’s Western Show?

Taylor Sheridan’s modern Western Yellowstone has not just led

the resurgence of the revitalized Western genre, but has been one

of the most successful TV shows in our modern era. The wild success

of the show and its influence on the real locations has led some to question just how realistic Yellowstone’s portrayal of ranch life is. It certainly seems authentic when watching Yellowstone, soon to release season 5, part 2, on a TV screen, but that doesn’t mean it’s true to life.

Yellowstone, starring the recently departed Kevin Costner, tells the story of the warring Dutton family, led by John Dutton, patriarch and owner of the Yellowstone Ranch in Montana, the largest ranch in the state. The Duttons fight with each other, land developers, tribal nations, and others to keep their ranch intact as the modern world threatens to destroy their traditional way of life. There’s quite a bit that Yellowstone gets right about ranching, particularly the pride the Duttons have in their ranch and working the land. However, plenty of elements are exaggerated for the show, and not at all accurate to real life.

Yellowstone Isn’t Based On A Specific True Story – But Has Real-Life Inspirations
Ranches Are Passed Down From Generation To Generation

Of course, Yellowstone isn’t an adaptation of a true story. The Duttons are fictional characters and their story is also entirely fictional. That said, their general story and family dynamic might have been ripped straight from any ranching family in America. Just like with Yellowstone’s cast of characters, ranching is a family business, with ranches being passed down from generation to generation. Depending on the size of the ranch and how successful it is, that can mean quite a bit of money flows back and forth and a ranching family can grow quite wealthy in a few generations, though it’s very rare.

While the drama of the Duttons is exaggerated for a soapy drama TV show, real ranching families can butt heads, clash over arguments, and have different ideas about how best to run the family business.

Working closely with family can lead to friction. While the drama of the Duttons is exaggerated for a soapy drama TV show, real ranching families can butt heads, clash over arguments, and have different ideas about how best to run the family business. There’s no separation between family and business, or between business and home; it’s all intertwined. That’s a recipe for tension, and it can certainly form cracks in relationships. Still, the drama of Yellowstone is more heightened than reality.

The most realistic part of Yellowstone is the Dutton family ranch itself. While not one to hop in front of a microphone or camera often, creator Taylor Sheridan has talked in the past about spending lots of time on a ranch as a kid, a ranch his mother bought in Cranfills Gap, Texas, so her kids would learn to be part of the outdoors. Sheridan grew up off and on at the ranch and spent weekends of his teenage years wrangling horses and riding. The authentic feel of Yellowstone’s ranch life is thanks to Sheridan having lived it.

That’s evident in the little details about the show. In an interview with Variety, rancher Jessie Jarvis explained that a number of things about Yellowstone are accurate, right down to the clothing brands they wear: Kimes Ranch clothing and Greeley Hat and American Hat are all real brands that ranchers trust. The horse riding is also very true to life, too. As one watches Yellowstone, you may notice scenes where riders in the background will be taking horses through steps in the arena; those steps are called reining patterns and they’re all performed by real riders, not actors.

Some Of Yellowstone’s Biggest Struggles Are True To Life
Land Loss & Real Estate Encroachment Are Real Issues For American Ranchers

Yellowstone is not a show without drama, both internal and external to the Duttons. In the same interview, Jarvis mentioned the Duttons’ struggles are accurate to real life, to the point that it is sometimes hard for her to watch because it was impossible to escape the problems of her own ranch life when watching the show. Central to that, and a topic that has come up long before Yellowstone shed light on it, is the loss of land and encroachment. The population is growing and moving, and it’s harder for ranching families to keep their large lands intact.

The COVID-19 pandemic only exacerbated that struggle. As countless articles and news reports explored during the pandemic, lots of people, especially young professionals, fled city life for quieter mountain towns and rural escapes. Sometimes, that’s been to a town’s benefit, as they inject sometimes struggling locations with more money and more business. Other times, though, it leads to a clash between ranchers and land developers as the former struggle to keep their lands from the latter. The balance between developing resources and land is a hard one to strike, and ranches and farms across America are finding themselves losing that fight.

 

Related articles

Kelly Reilly Says John’S Absence Was ‘Always’ Part Of Taylor Sheridan’S Yellowstone Ending

Although certain aspects of Yellowstone’s ending are being kept top secret, there is one part of the show’s final episodes that is public knowledge: Kevin Costner will…

Kelly Reilly Admits Kevin Costner’s Absence From ‘Yellowstone’ Didn’t Affect The Ending

The final season of Yellowstone is being kept under lock and key, as one would expect, but we do know one thing: John Dutton will not be…

‘1923’ Season 2: Spencer Dutton Finally Comes Home!

1923 star Brandon Sklenar, who portrays Spencer Dutton in the Yellowstone prequel series, has teased what to expect from the Dutton family’s story in season 2, hinting at some dark…

Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2 Episode 1: The Death of Monica!

With Yellowstone nearing its end, fans are bracing for a major character death. The hit western drama has never been shy when it comes to killing off…

Kevin Costner’s Yellowstone Season 5 Part 2 Absence Was Always Taylor Sheridan’s Plan, Star Reveals

Yellowstone star Kelly Reilly reveals that it was always creator Taylor Sheridan’s plan to have Kevin Costner be absent from season 5, part 2. After first airing in…

SHOCKING NEWS!! Kevin Costner Surrounded by Fans, Embraces Susan Sarandon After ‘Horizon 2’ Receives 3-Minute Standing Ovation at Venice

Kevin Costner’s second installment of his Western franchise, “Horizon: An American Saga – Chapter Two,” garnered an enthusiastic three-minute standing ovation at the Venice Film Festival on…