Emmerdale fans ‘baffled’ over ‘unrealistic’ Belle plot hole

In Emmerdale, Belle Dingle headed off to Shetland to find Nate and bring him home. But fans all noticed one major plot hole in the storyline.

Nate’s body still remains undiscovered in Emmerdale. And right now, everyone (except for John) believes that Nate left to start a new life. But up until last night (May 22), they believed that new life was in Shetland.

However, the Dingles are now aware that Nate never went to Shetland. So, the mystery of where he is continues. But fans were extremely distracted by Belle’s plot-hole.

Tracy and Belle in the Woolpack
Belle decided to search for Nate (Credit: ITV)

Emmerdale Belle drove to Shetland to find Nate

The only reason anyone knows Nate isn’t where he said he was going is because Belle drove to Shetland to find him. Then came home whenever she discovered he never went.

Once Belle heard just how much Tracy was struggling, she decided something needed to be done about it. And because she used to be close to Nate, she felt she could get through to him.

Of course, Nate isn’t actually just being a horrible dad. Thanks to John Sugden, Nate is dead and his body is in the lake. And John has made it known to us that he will do anything to protect his secret.

Emmerdale is prone to a plot hole or two occasionally. But everyone was shocked at how quickly Belle managed to get to and from Shetland.

To get from Yorkshire to Shetland it takes approximately 18 hours – including the drive and the ferry. So, it seems highly impossible someone could do it within 24 hours. Yet, Belle did.

John stops Belle from ringing the police
Belle went to and from Shetland within 24 hours (Credit: ITV)

Fans slam plot hole

Fans took to X to share their confusion at the soap, believing it should have known the distance between places.

One wrote: “Having Belle drive (yes, drive) to Shetland and back again in 24 hours may be the most unrealistic thing Emmerdale has ever done. The ferry alone is minimum 14.5 hours each way and that’s not including the drive to Aberdeen to catch it.”

Another joked: “Did Belle use the millennium falcon to go to Shetland?”

“Belle looks remarkably good considering she’s just done a round trip to Shetland within 24 hours!”

A confused fan penned: “So Belle has been to Shetland and back within 24 hours??”

Another commented: “Belle, that was a quick trip.”

Related articles

Both grooms missing in Emmerdale as John and Aaron’s wedding takes dramatic twist

John Sugden remains on edge (Picture: ITV) John Sugden (Oliver Farnworth) knows he’s on borrowed time and his subconscious is telling him as much. Some incredible upcoming episodes…

Emmerdale Spoiler: John’s Wedding Escape Plan Exposed | Shocking Twist Before the Vows!

Emmerdale fans, brace yourselves. What should have been a romantic day filled with heartfelt vows, flowers, and forever promises is about to take a jaw-dropping detour. The…

Emmerdale confirms who calls social services on Joe Tate in early ITVX episode

Emmerdale is lining up more trouble at Home Farm, as vulnerable Clemmie Reed calls social services about Joe Tate. The surprise twist airs in Friday’s episode, as it…

Emmerdale spoilers for tomorrow (Friday): Cain worries about Nate as John takes action

In Emmerdale spoilers for tomorrow night, Friday May 23, concern over Nate continues to grow within the Dingle family after Belle discovers her nephew never arrived in…

John Sets Up A Calculated Trap For Moira | Emmerdale

The latest Emmerdale episode reveals a tense and emotional battle unfolding between John and Moira, centered around trust, forgiveness, and unexpected danger. At the heart of this…

Emmerdale legend’s return axed FOREVER as fan favourite secretly moves to Australia – and abandons her family

EMMERDALE has ruled out a return for a soap legend with a brutal off-screen storyline. The ITV soap has dropped a bombshell about a popular character amid speculation that…