Emmerdale last night: ‘Brilliantly realistic’ or a ‘low-rent Casualty’ – fans in huge debate over Jacob standalone episode

In last night’s Emmerdale episode (January 2), the show once again provided a

unique standalone episode following Jacob Gallagher’s first day at his A&E placement.

While he was initially excited for the experience. His first day quickly turned into hell as he made a huge mess-up.

Things kept getting progressively worse for Jacob, and by the end of the episode he looked like he had been there for more than one day.

While Emmerdale was trying to highlight the importance of A&E workers, along with the stress on the healthcare system. The response seems to be divided.

Jacob’s first day at A&E was a disaster. (Credit: ITV)

Jacob Emmerdale episode was ‘realistic’

On one side of things fans praised the storytelling for how realistic it was. The A&E department was busy and chaotic – similar to the real life situations.

Fans praised the Emmerdale episode in the comments of their Instagram post.

One wrote: “It was very realistic! I’m an ex-nurse and saw this on the A&E wards with my own eyes. It’s a very stressful job.”

Another added: “It was an emotional episode today. Seeing it from different people’s eyes, who are all going through difficult times. Well done Emmerdale.”

A third viewer praised: “What a rollercoaster. Brilliant writing, acting and production.”

However, not everybody appeared to share the same thought process, as many others thought the episode didn’t actually need to happen.

The Emmerdale episode has divided fans. (Credit: ITV)

Fans slam ‘low-rate Casualty episode’

After Jacob made the huge error of telling Marlon and Rhona that the teenage stab victim was April even though he didn’t see her, his boss gave him some harsh words – right in front of everyone else.

Viewers felt that wasn’t necessary and while he deserved to be told off, it should have happened in private.

A viewer commented: “I could have written this. Knew it wasn’t going to be April and the old guy was going to die. This was like a really low-rate Casualty episode.”

Others seemed to agree with this view. Another added: “That nurse would have been reported immediately. Mistakes happen and they are learned from. Damaging the confidence of a starter is not the way to go.”

A third simply wrote: “This episode was unnecessary and boring.”

While it may have gotten mixed reviews from the viewers, it seems the Emmerdale episode certainly got people talking.

Related articles

EAGLE – EYED Emmerdale fans shocked as they spot A Touch Of Frost star on soap – did you see her?

In Emmerdale spoilers, Belle gets a heart-warming Christmas treat as Vinny and Gabby track down Piper the Dog for her in emotional scenes. Elsewhere, April rebels and…

BREAKING NEWS !! Emmerdale Ruby’s evil dad’s m.u.r.d.e.r ‘confirmed’ after giveaway clue – and fans are thrilled

**Emmerdale: Ruby’s Father’s Murder ‘Confirmed’ After Clue Sparks Fan Excitement** *Emmerdale* has teased a shocking plot twist involving Ruby Fox-Miligan and her abusive father, Anthony. Recently, viewers…

BREAKING NEWS! Emmerdale Tom return hints, Corrie exit outcome and more soap spoilers

This week’s biggest soap news features Emmerdale star James Chase discussing the potential for a future return of the notorious Tom King after his dramatic trial. Additionally,…

“Very Sad News: Emmerdale 2025 Spoilers Reveal Shocking ‘Return from the Dead’ April Tragedy & Massive Exits!

Emmerdale fans are in for a heart-wrenching start to 2025, with tragedy and shocking twists on the horizon . As the iconic ITV soap continues to captivate…

“BREAKING NEWS!! *Emmerdale* Fans ‘Work Out’ Joe Tate’s Shocking Plan for Noah Dingle – And It’s Bad News!

Emmerdale fans have a theory on Joe Tate’s return to the village and why he is so keen to get to know his half-brother Noah Dingle –…

BREAKING NEWS !! Emmerdale Christmas and New Year spoilers: First look as Belle is reunited with Piper the Dog

In Emmerdale spoilers, Belle gets a heart-warming Christmas treat as Vinny and Gabby track down Piper the Dog for her in emotional scenes. Elsewhere, April rebels and…