Emmerdale reveals one key clue which could prove Cain didn’t kill Nate

Emmerdale‘s Cain Dingle comes out fighting tonight as he wrongly faces suspicion over Nate Robinson’s murder.

Cain quickly becomes the prime suspect as the police start to investigate Nate’s grisly demise – and immediately focus on the wrong people.

As detectives confirm that the body found in the lake is Nate, there’s little time for Cain to grieve for his son as he’s hauled down to the station for questioning.

There’s big trouble for the village bad boy when he fails to immediately come clean about the fight he had with Nate shortly before his disappearance.

cain dingle, emmerdale

Once other key witnesses mention this among Nate’s last known movements, it makes Cain look like he has something to hide.

Fortunately, Cain has an ace up his sleeve – letting the detectives know that he tried to phone Nate at the end of April.

“His phone – I called him a few weeks ago on his mobile and someone answered,” Cain explains.

“I don’t know [who it was] – they didn’t say anything. But whoever’s done this, they were listening to his messages.”

cain dingle emmerdale

Handing over the proof on his phone log, he adds: “Why would I call him if I knew he was dead? Now that you’ve got some actual evidence, can you let me go?”

Fans can see more about how the investigation plays out when the episode airs at 7pm on ITV1 tonight, or it’s also streaming early now on ITVX.

Over the coming weeks, viewers will see the Emmerdale villagers turn on each other as speculation and theories circulate over who killed Nate.

John Sugden – the real killer – returns home next week and tries to cover his tracks.

Meanwhile, Nate’s estranged wife Tracy Robinson also faces suspicion and becomes desperate to clear her name.

Related articles

Who’s the Body in Emmerdale’s Lake? New Theory Sparks Debate

In Emmerdale, secrets don’t stay buried — especially not when they’re tangled with blood and betrayal. What began as a desperate confession from Ruby Milligan about her…

Tracy Accuses Cain Of Killing Nate | Emmerdale

Emmerdale has never shied away from wrenching emotion or explosive revelations, but few arcs have been as soul-tearing and suspenseful as the unraveling aftermath of Nate Robinson’s…

Emmerdale Star Reveals Grim Future for Aidan Moore’s Character

Emmerdale fans were left reeling as Aiden Moore’s future on the ITV soap took a dramatic turn, with actor Jeff Dignon revealing some crucial updates about his…

Emmerdale fans ‘turned off’ British Soap Awards insisting: ‘It was rigged for EastEnders to win’

Emmerdale only walked away with two wins at the British Soap Awards, and it’s safe to say that fans are absolutely fuming. Last night (June 5), the…

Emmerdale: Jon Sugden’s Shocking Secrets Unravel After Nate Robinson’s Body Discovery

Emmerdale fans have been left reeling as the long-awaited secrets of Jon Sugden (played by Ryan Hawley) begin to come to light, thanks to the recent discovery…

Emmerdale star’s real-life brother from rival soap sobs as they go head to head for award

  Emmerdale star Amelia Flanagan was seen in tears when she accepted the award for Best Young Performer at the British Soap Awards 2025. The 16-year-old, who plays April Windsor…