With the big limo crash and icy lake stunt coming up in Emmerdale, a new fan theory has predicted that Caleb will drown his brother Cain in the frozen lake.
Caleb Miligan recently discovered that Anthony had been telling the truth about Cain sleeping with his wife, Ruby, and he broke down in the toilet.
With Caleb set on revenge, fans think the limo crash will provide the perfect opportunity.
![](https://i0.wp.com/emmerdale-insider.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/14_02_emm_caleb_cain_02.jpg?resize=640%2C439&ssl=1)
The upcoming limo crash
Scenes that will air this week and next will show a massive ice stunt involving two limos and a frozen lake.
The villagers split up into boys’ and girls’ groups as they climb into their respective limos for their big nights out.
The limos are dropped off with no drivers so Charity and Caleb step up as chauffeurs. Unbeknownst to Cain Dingle, Caleb is still angry and is determined to avoid being near his brother.
Neither trip goes as planned, with the atmosphere in the girls’ limo chaotic. Meanwhile, a huge row breaks out in the boys’ limo. With the drivers both distracted by what is going on, the two cars swerve off the road.
Both vehicles are involved in separate accidents – but one limo is put in a particularly scary position when it crashes into an icy lake.
Promo shots show a hand desperately pounding on the ice from the depths of the water… but who is it?
![](https://i0.wp.com/emmerdale-insider.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/14_02_emm_caleb_drive_04.jpg?resize=640%2C360&ssl=1)
Cain and Caleb fan theory
On Reddit, a fan shared their theory over what they believe will happen. They think Caleb’s desire for revenge could result in Cain falling through the ice.
They said: “What if it’s the men’s limo that ends up on the ice and most get away safely bar Cain and Caleb, so what if Caleb takes his revenge on Cain on the ice and tries to drown him?”
Another fan had a similar thought, writing: “I think the person under the ice will be either Cain or Caleb, who will have been brawling prior to the crash and caused the limo to go off the road.
“Then whichever brother isn’t trapped will perform a heroic rescue. My guess is that Caleb is trapped and Cain saves him. But he is unconscious because of the cold etc. Hence the scenes of Caleb in a hospital bed.”
It’s not long now before fans will find out the truth.