Emmerdale spoilers: Anthony to shoot himself in huge whodunnit twist? Fan theory explored

This week sparks the end of Anthony Fox in Emmerdale as he is killed off as part of a big whodunnit story. But a new fan theory has predicted that Anthony will end his own life.

Anthony arrived in the village a few months ago and viewers quickly discovered that he had abused his daughter Ruby when she was young.

While there are many people in the village, including Ruby Fox-Miligan herself, who’d like to see Anthony dead, viewers are predicting a huge twist.

Caleb points a gun at Anthony
Caleb points a gun at Anthony (Credit: ITV)

Anthony Fox in Emmerdale

Shortly after Anthony arrived in the Dales, a special flashback episode revealed that Anthony had sexually abused Ruby when she was a child.

In the flashback scene, a young Ruby was seen celebrating her 16th birthday. Her father then approached her in her bedroom, while Ruby begged “not again, not today.”

Ruby had kept the secret for over 30 years, but last week she bravely confronted her father over what he had put her through. She also ordered a DNA test, which horrifically revealed that Anthony is Steph Miligan’s real father.

Chas and Caleb soon figured out the truth and news started to spread around the village about Anthony’s history. After Caleb ordered Anthony to get into his car, a flash forward scene showed a bloodied Anthony dead on the floor.

Caleb threatens Anthony with a gun, and Ruby, Chas, Cain, Aaron, Laurel and Nicola also all have motive, but will any of them kill Anthony?

Will Anthony take his own life? (Credit: ITV)

New whodunnit fan theory

Emmerdale fans have suggested that the culprit could be Anthony himself.

Taking to X, a fan wrote: “Money on Anthony being that out of it after all the batterings, he gets the gun, fumbles and shoots himself. All major characters survive a jail sentence.”

Another fan had a similar idea, writing: “I think Anthony tries to grab the gun and it goes off.”

A third fan wrote: “Caleb hands the gun to Anthony and tells him to do the right thing.”

Related articles

Robert is dangerously close to exposing killer John in Emmerdale – but a shock twist follows

Robert Sugden knows his brother his bad news (Picture: ITV) Robert Sugden (Ryan Hawley) has had John Sugden’s (Oliver Farnworth) card marked since he met him in Emmerdale….

MOIRA DINGLE ARRESTED AFTER SHOCK ATTACK IN EMMERDALE! 🤯💣 CAIN ISSUES A DEADLY ULTIMATUM — WHOSE SIDE WILL THEY CHOOSE?

Mackenzie Boyd (Lawrence Robb) misses the moment as Charity Dingle (Emma Atkins) goes ahead with her plan to carry a baby for granddaughter Sarah Sugden (Katie Hill). Also,…

Emmerdale Bombshell: Cain’s Death Scene Will Leave You in Tears!

The Silent Storm Within: Cain Dingle’s Most Heartbreaking Battle in Emmerdale Emmerdale has never been short on drama, death, or dark twists — but nothing could have…

Major Emmerdale couple facing split in ITVX release as ultimatum is issued

Mackenzie Boyd made a discovery (Picture: ITV) The following article contains spoilers from an episode of Emmerdale that hasn’t aired on ITV1 yet, but can be viewed on ITVX. Mackenzie…

GRAHAM FOSTER RETURNS FROM THE GRAVE – HIS DARK LEGACY HAUNTS KIM & JOE IN EMMERDALE!

In the world of Emmerdale, where alliances shift like Yorkshire weather and betrayal is never far behind, some ghosts never rest. One such ghost is Graham Foster….

BOMBSHELL TWIST IN EMMERDALE! ROBERT SUGDEN EXPOSES HIS BROTHER JOHN IN DEADLY COVER-UP

Robert Sugden (Ryan Hawley) is drawn back into his half-brother John’s (Oliver Farnworth) dark web of lies in Monday’s (21st July 2025) episode of Emmerdale. Last week, John framed…