Emmerdale fans genuinely believe that John Sugden lied about who

Aidan Moore is and that he’s actually the man himself.

There’s been a lot of speculation as to who Aidan Moore could be, and

despite John providing the answers… fans aren’t convinced he’s telling the truth. Fair enough.

Emmerdale fans reckon John himself is Aidan Moore

Ever since they spotted John acting really guarded around a dog tag with the name ‘Aidan Moore’ on it, fans started to wonder who Aidan could be.

With John eventually admitting to Vic that Aidan was an old army friend who died, the way he looked at the dog tag again last night (Monday, December 16), suggested that there was more to the story. Something is definitely suss, that’s for sure!

Now, fans are convinced that John himself is actually Aidan and has been trying to fool Aaron and Vic with a different identity all along.

One fan wrote: “I think John is really Aidan.”

Another fan agreed and suggested: “Imposter John Sugden.”

A third person added: “Without Robert there is no drama, because surely Aidan Moore is really John or his ex lover. Aaron and John go bonding about the loss of their loved ones, they say ILY in the woods and they surely disappear for weeks (until next year.) That’s not a good story.”

So, who actually is Aidan Moore?

Right, so here’s all we know so far. Aidan was an old friend of John’s, meeting him in the army.

While out in Afghanistan, Aidan got injured and John had promised to save him. However, his injuries were too severe and he died, with John breaking his promise.

John couldn’t live with the guilt and decided to leave the army and head off to live in a campervan.

But, John is still so guarded and secretive when it comes to this dog tag! There must be more to the story, right?

But, who was Aidan Moore? Or, who is Aidan Moore? Is John the guy himself? Just what is he keeping from Aaron and Vic?