In the gripping premiere of Season 19 of “Sister Wives,” titled “A House Divided,”

Cody and Robyn Brown emerge as the series’ primary villains amid the chaos of the

fractured Brown family. As Christine Brown successfully moves on from the

turmoil, the tension between her and Cody, along with Robyn, is palpable during a baby sprinkle event. Christine’s distance from them highlights Cody’s jealousy as she thrives while he and Robyn grapple with their declining relationship. As the season unfolds, viewers witness Cody and Robyn entangled in their own cycle of blame and denial, with Cody asserting that Christine and Janelle are punishing him by excluding him.

This claim falls flat for many fans who are frustrated by his refusal to accept responsibility for the family’s fractures. The dynamics are further complicated by the recent tragic loss of Janelle and Cody’s son, Garrison, which has intensified the emotional turmoil within the family. Robyn’s position as both a perceived victim and an enabler is increasingly scrutinized, revealing her complicity in the family’s unraveling. As she struggles to maintain her standing as Cody’s last wife, the cracks in her facade grow more evident, leaving fans questioning whether Robyn or Cody truly deserves the title of the season’s biggest villain.