Virgin River backlash as Charmaine’s season 5 birth scene labelled ‘ridiculous’ by fans

Virgin River finally saw Charmaine give birth to the twins in season five

but fans were far from happy with the key scene

Virgin River fans had been long awaiting Charmaine to go into labour

and many couldn’t help but share their dissatisfied reaction when the time came. In the very first series of the romantic Netflix drama, Charmaine (played by Lauren Hammersley) announced she was pregnant, making everyone believe that Jack Sheridan (Martin Henderson) was the father.

It wasn’t too long before it was revealed she was expecting twins but in an unexpected twist in series four, she confesses her unborn children are not really his.

She had been pregnant throughout the first five series of Virgin River with a mystery surrounding the real dad’s identity so many were excited to see Charmaine go into labour in the new episodes.

However, many subscribers who know about giving birth to twins were not happy with how the birth was portrayed.

Kicking off an angry Reddit thread, one viewer commented: “I work in the birth world (doula and LC) and the way birth is portrayed on this show makes me want to eat glass.

“I’ve been so disappointed by how literally every birth attended by Mel – supposedly a highly experienced and crunchyish midwife – is mom doing DIRECTED PUSHING ON HER BACK.

“Anyone who has either had or witnessed a physiologic birth knows this is NOT how it goes. The breech birth at the weed camp was the only one even remotely close to accurate, and still left a lot to be desired.

“I’ve been so disappointed by how literally every birth attended by Mel – supposedly a highly experienced and crunchyish midwife – is mom doing DIRECTED PUSHING ON HER BACK.

“Anyone who has either had or witnessed a physiologic birth knows this is NOT how it goes. The breech birth at the weed camp was the only one even remotely close to accurate, and still left a lot to be desired.

“Omg I was waiting for someone to post this!” a fan rejoiced.

“I have twins and when I saw that twin birth in that office I was like no freaking way.

“Mine was actually not dramatic at all, but it’s high risk so lots of precautions had to be taken regardless. I was like what tf is going on.”

A second agreed: “Yeah, I had twins three weeks ago and was laughing at this scene.

“My real-life birth was way more dramatic. There were no less than 12 doctors/nurses, etc in the room when I gave birth. On the show, they were like ‘oh, Charmaine, you might have pre-eclampsia’ but then she was cool.”

Another added: “Her whole labour and delivery made me roll my eyes. I’ve had eight (yes that’s a lot I’m aware) and it was so fake and unrealistic.”

Related articles

Virgin River fans ecstatic as Martin Henderson shares season 6 update

Virgin River fans were ecstatic when series lead Martin Henderson dropped a thrilling update on the next outing. Season six hasn’t got an official release date so…

Why ‘Virgin River’ Star Alexandra Breckenridge Predicts Mel Will Be a ‘Nurturing and Patient Mother’

We first fell in love with Melinda “Mel” Monroe (Alexandra Breckenridge) when the caring nurse practitioner came to Virgin River to escape her painful past, and unexpectedly…

UPCOMING: Virgin River season 6 on Netflix: everything we know so far

Virgin River has become one of the best Netflix series with its addictive sleepy town drama that’s played out across five seasons so far. The series has…

Virgin River’s Cameron branded ‘creep’ as fans blast him for ‘inappropriate’ behaviour

Virgin River fans haven’t taken too kindly to Dr Cameron Hayek, with many claiming he has a lot of “red flags”. Fans of Netflix’s Virgin River have…

‘Virgin River’ season 6 expected to release date on OTT

Everything to Know About Virgin River Season 6 A lot happens in Virgin River — the town and the series — each season, but Season 5 of…

Virgin River Season 6: When release date announcement can happen, and all about Alexandra Breckenridge’s hints

The release date for Virgin River Season 6 could be announced soon. Here is everything we know. Alexandra Breckenridge’s Hints As 2024 nears its end, fans are…