Yellowstone is ending with season 5 part 2 in November,

but fans are already praying for one couple’s story to continue on.

It all started on February 16, when the Paramount Network series’

official Instagram posted a throwback season 2 clip between Beth Dutton (Kelly Reilly) and Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser). As the duo sit overlooking the Dutton Ranch and discuss Beth’s father John (Kevin Costner) forcing her brother Kayce (Luke Grimes) to play a bigger role in the family business, Rip feels like his place as John’s right-hand man is being threatened. This leaves Beth to bring up a pivotal moment between the two from years ago.

“I remember the first time I saw you,” she tells Rip in the clip. “So wild, so angry. God, you were beautiful. I remember the way you looked at him. Such devotion — I was so jealous. And the way he’d look at you. I always worried that he’d love you more someday. But he doesn’t… don’t leave.”“That’s nothing that was ever in doubt,” he responds. “This is my family, whether y’all think of me that way or not.”

When fans were reminded of the memorable moment between Beth and Rip, they immediately voiced a request about the characters’ — and subsequently, the show’s — future.